Chef Tim Sizer oversees Timothy’s, Tim’s Too

The Pan Fri Pork Potstickers pictured here is one of many original appetizers featured at Tim’s Too Asian Grill in St. Joseph.
UNION PIER - Tim Sizer is ready to serve you a dinner you’ll never forget in Union Pier … and in St. Joseph.
With no overlapping main dishes, sauces or desserts, owner and executive chef Sizer is overseeing two completely different fine dining establishments in Berrien County.
Different, that is, except for their focus on fresh ingredients and Sizer’s own special recipes.
Timothy’s at Gordon Beach Inn in Union Pier is a full-service restaurant specializing in seafood entrees and upscale cuisine.
Tim’s Too Asian Grill in downtown St. Joseph is a “create your own stir fry” restaurant that allows customers to help build the perfect meal.
“They are totally night and day,” explained Sizer, “other than Asian influences.”

John Sutton pours Joe Herman a glass of wine while Claudia Hanley looks on duing a recent visit to Timothy’s in Union Pier.
And those influences are reflected in the flavors and tastes offered in each menu, with such entrees as Ahi tuna poached in extra virgin olive oil with a mango salad and Pacific Rim Thai grouper.
From the outside, the restaurants certainly look nothing alike.
Housed inside an old inn and nestled next to the woods, Timothy’s at Gor- don Beach Inn features a cabin-style environment complete with fireplaces, hardwood floors and exposed ceiling joists inside and around the dining room area.
In contrast, Tim’s Too, which is located in the middle of downtown St. Jo- seph, advertises a modern environment with Far East decor and furnishings, hanging lamps and Asian-themed uniforms worn by servers.
“This is a create-your- own stir fry restaurant where you come in and get to pick and choose and design your entire meal around your own liking,” Sizer said, “tasting the sauces and mixing them together to get whatever profile you want.”
He said Timothy’s at Gordon Beach Inn is a full-service Harbor Country restaurant - “one of the more upscale restaurants in the area.”
Timothy’s at Gordon Beach Inn features mouthwatering entrees such as coconut and macadamia nut crusted grouper, miso glazed wild king salmon and Caribbean spiced Delmonico steak, with a variety of side selections including deep-fried spin-ach, roasted tomato soup and a choice of specialty salads.
“When we opened, we really strived to use the freshest ingredients,” Sizer said. “Everything is made from scratch, all of our dressings, all of our desserts, we don’t buy anything that’s prepared.”
And because Timothy’s at Gordon Beach Inn specializes in dishes from the sea, the 14 seafood items on its menu are less than 48 hours old, and flown in two to three times per week from Chicago, and once a week from Hawaii.
“It’s not like being on the coast of Florida and being able to get fish that same day out of the water, but with the technology today, you can get fresh fish that’s less than 48 hours old,” Sizer said.
At Tim’s Too, customers can pick from a selection of rice and noodles (such as long grain wheat rice, Chinese egg and oriental spinach noodles), vegetables and meats, and sauces, including woo doo diablo, spicy lime basil and mint mango. Also offered are appetizers such as potstickers and spicy sesame peanut noodles.
As with Timothy’s at Gordon Beach Inn, everything at Tim’s Too is served fresh and made from scratch.
“We don’t buy anything prepared,” Sizer explained. “All the sauces were made by me and designed by me. There are no overlapping sauces (with Timothy’s). They are all totally different. Our vegetables are cut everyday for that day’s service. Our fish is cut today for tonight. All of our meats and poultry are cut the same day for the service that day. So we try and do the same thing here as there. Something very consistent, something of value and something that, hopefully, tastes good to the consumer.”
Sizer, born and raised in St. Joseph, studied the culinary arts at Johnson & Wales University in Prov- idence, R.I., before moving to Florida, where he ran two seafood restaurants owned by the same family, one in St. Augustine and the other in Atlantic Beach. He credits the development of his culinary talents and expertise to his time spent there, because he was allowed to experiment and use the tools he learned in school.
After 13 years of living in Florida, however, he decided it was time to move back to his home town.
“It was time to either open up a restaurant or just forget about it and work for somebody else my whole life. And I thought, if I’m going to do it, I might as well do it now.”
And in May of 2001, Sizer opened Timothy’s to great success. He credited much of this achievement to his staff’s talent and expertise, and to the market at the time, which he said was in need of a new restaurant. He also noted that the restaurant’s clean and simple ambiance, so unlike the fancy establishments in the city across the lake, attracted many vacationers and customers from Chicago.
Another benefit was gearing his menu toward fish, where he said he was more experienced (and where few area restaurants specialized) and then striving to keep the quality and flavor of the meals consistent so his business would garner a strong reputation.
“One of our main goals was to make sure if you came and got a good meal and came back two or three weeks later and got the same thing, the meal would taste exactly the same,” he explained. “Consistency is one of the key’s to a new restaurant’s success.”
Then, almost six years later, he opened Tim’s Too Asian Grill in July of 2007.
He said this was partly in response to his love of Asian cuisine, and partly to slow winter business in Harbor Country, during which he operated Timothy’s despite the lack of customers compared to the busy summer season.
“I’ve got 15 to 25 employees at any one time and they deserve to work year round, and it’s also hard to lay people off and try to rehire them in the spring every year. That would be a crazy cycle to try and have to do. So I thought about having a restaurant that would be busy all year round,” he said.
Sizer said he always enjoyed Asian cuisine: the flavors, fresh vegetables and the light sauces. He said it is a very nutritious, and now popular, cuisine.
Besides its wide range of vegetables and meats, Tim’s Too offers 24 different sauces (from mild to hot) for customers to mix and match with their selections. Tasting cups are provided, along with a list of suggested combinations, so customers won’t have to guess how their final product will taste.
And just recently he’s added a full service bar, complete with cold sake and a selection of Asian beers.
Lunches at Tim’s Too start under $10, with dinners around $13. He pointed out that this was a half to a third the cost of the entrees at Timothy’s at Gordon Beach Inn.
“My pallet is kind of normal,” he explained. “So if I like something, almost anyone is going to like it … We use a lot of ginger root, garlic, lemon grass, coconut root, some things you might not have seen in a smaller town … there just wasn’t anyplace like this.”
Timothy’s is located at 16220 Lake Shore Road in Union Pier. Spring hours are Wednesday through Sunday from 5 p.m. For more information, call (269) 469-0900, or visit Timothy’s online at www.timothysrestaurant.com.
Tim’s Too is located at 511 Pleasant Street in St. Joseph. Spring hours are Monday through Saturday from 11 a.m. For more information, call (269) 985-0094, or visit Tim’s Too online at www.timstoo.com.
By Matt Fritz
Harbor Country News staff writer
Posted under Uncategorized